#3 The lady with the Dog

 Rating: 6/10


Since this story talks about cheating on someone, which is morally wrong, I thought that this story would end with two main characters losing everything and getting only love. Unfortunately, the story is open-ended. If I had a chance to change the story, I would end this story by making Gurov and Anna escape from their own family but soon regrets and break up. Not only the ending, but I also didn’t satisfy with the main characters. Anna Sergeyevna, who looks naive, is not kind and innocent. Even though she felt guilty about her husband, she doesn’t stop the relationship with Gurov. Gurov, a playboy, had cheated on others a lot, which is wrong.  The short story was interesting that I was able to get into it, (I almost give it 10/10) however I didn’t like the ending and  rated 6/10.

댓글

  1. Garrioch2022년 3월 9일 오후 5:04

    I also don't like the ending. I don't think many readers actually do, and Chekhov doesn't care! He just wants us to see the question and come to our own conclusions, and it might be that your wish for that type of ending does eventually come to them. Or not? Who knows. Love is complex, and makes people do selfish things. But are they selfish??? That's the point. Good work!

    답글삭제

댓글 쓰기

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

#Goosberries

 Rating: 6/10 Selfish VS Altruistic This short story talks about altruism (Ivan) VS selfishness (Ivan's brother Nikolai). I felt that the author placed the altruistic character in the story to contrast and strongly criticize Nikolai. But, was Nikolai selfish from the start? At the first time, Nikolai had one great goal, being a landowner and growing gooseberries. Since he only focused on achieving his goal, he became selfish. This story tells that being blind with a strong desire is dangerous. I liked the message of the story (more than the lady with a dog). But the story is still vague and hard to understand clearly. Especially why author put a description that Aliokhin hadn’t take a shower for a long time that the water turned brown? Therefore, I rated 6.5 out of 10. (If teacher sees this blog, please make a comment why about my question toward Aliokhin)
자세한 내용 보기

#2 The Student

After 1st reading)  Rating: 5 /10  <The Student> written by Checkov has a vivid description that expresses the atmosphere of cold deep winter. However, I couldn’t get the author’s message at all. It was hard to understand the message, especially Ivan's enlightenment after he talks the story to the window and her daughter. Even though this very short story has a sharp depiction, getting into the story and understand the author’s message was hard.  After 2nd reading) Rating: 8.5/10 In the first reading, matching this short story with a hero's journey was tough. After having discussion time in the class, I could understand the hidden message. The story seems blurred when I didn't catch the hidden meaning, but after reading it twice, the story was interesting. Especially the scene of Vasilisa's tear made me imagine the unknown story of the daughter and mom. To compare this story with hero journey stage 6, which is a step of enemy and testes, Ivan testes Vasilisa and h...
자세한 내용 보기